Please review my banner design

[admans]

Hello,

Just made few banners for promotional purposes. Please suggest and rate the banners.

Banner 1:

Banner 2:

http://img367.imageshack.us/img367/5915/bannerwwwmobileaddictcom6fi.gif

Thanx.

Regards,

Admans.

 

[Surfz]

not bad if ur a newbie in making banners anyway keep up the good work

 

[martin ewing]

Hi,
IMO, banners are cool and simple in designing. You could also add creative slogan and pic there. However, banners look professional. Good work. Keep it up!:wink2:

 

[ryza]

i like the second one better.

 

[ServiceUptime]

Both banners are very good but...
First banner: text changes too fast,ie there should be longer delay since there are always such slow readers as I.
Second banner: too heavy. 140kb for banner is too much. it should be not more than 50kb.

 

[skaterguy452288]

The second banner rocks!